Didn’t last , I returned itI have bought this before and bought it again, so happy Amazon had it, Laura Geller was out of stock.? Great for us older girls especially I hate when lipstick bleeds onto the lines❤️This comes in an outer product box with ingredients listed.The pencil twists up. The tip is slanted, so you can get your lips really well. I got the shade “Radiant Rose.” It looks true to the product photos, which was nice. It’s really creamy. It glides right on, and has good pigment. I love the shade because it works well if I want to just line my lips and put a clear gloss over it. I also like it because I can just line and fill in my lips with this and put nothing over it. It feels moisturizing on the lips, but doesn’t fade off quickly. Of course, it fades when I eat and drink, but it fades nicely. Some lip liners when they fade, you’re left with like the outline on he edges of your lips, but lose the color you filled your lips in with. This doesn’t do that. It seems to fade evenly so it doesn’t look odd as it fades, which I really like!Overall, it’s a nice lip liner. Great color, great formula. But, it’s pretty darn pricey ($19 at the time of writing this review). I never see the point in paying higher prices for lip products like liners, glosses, lipsticks, etc. There are so many great drugstore options, I just don’t see the point in paying a higher price. So, this isn’t something I’ll purchase when I run out. But, if you don’t mind the price, it’s a nice formula.The color that I got matches my lips exactly. If I hadn't put it on myself , I honestly would have know there was anything on my lips. It's very matte. It does work though. It kept my lipstick from bleeding. I do think it's a little drying if you use it all over the lips. A little over priced for a lip liner, but it's still good.This is a good product to outline your lips. There was no pulling, or going over twice, that you get with pencil liners. It went on smoothly and in exactly the line I wanted.Not too thin or too thick. Angled.I think you need to find a liner that matches with your lips and this color was a good choice. I have used several lipstick shades on the inside part of my lips and they all work well with this outline. There’s not just one color choice for every liner.It stays on sufficiently longer than lipstick, but I have not found a product that last a long long time.Waterproof would mean you can eat and drink with it on, and I haven’t worn any lipstick or lip liner other than very matte products (that in my opinion look horrible), that will accomplish this. I can’t hold a company to that claim. There is just no winning on that score. This is no exception. Once you apply creamy or shiny lipstick to it, it’s not on its own. It behaves like the lipstick or you have on an outline of your lips. Your lipstick must be reapplied. * I write reviews to let you know how this product was for me, and to aid you in your decision to buy or not buy.I like the angled contour. I find it easier to line my lips with it over a pointed liner. I think the main thing is that I can keep my cupids bow looking natural more so than the pointed variety. They say that it "hugs natural curves", and I totally agree with that. I also agree that it has a hydrating feel. As for long lasting? eh, no not really. It fades evenly, but I wouldnt say it lingers all day. Maybe with added preparation.It glides on like a lip stick. It is creamy and matte. It isnt dry like a typical liner. This can be good or bad depending on what you are looking for. Likely nice for more dry lips.The "Nice Neutral" color is a light neutral. A little peachy and warm than I would normally go for, but i have to say it looks natural on my lips. I have fair skin with rosy lips- I rarely need added color. Despite having cool undertones, this color works well on me. I think it will work ok on most people. I can leave it as is or I can top it with a gloss.This lipliner is pretty short compared to many others but the quality is good. I got Radiant Rose and it matches my lip shade just about exactly. I tend to wear rose based lip colors so this liner will be fine with many of my lipsticks and lip glosses. It looks very natural and nice alone when I fill my lips in with the pencil as well.The pencil swivels up from the middle and has a slanted tip. It is pretty creamy and last for quite a while when I wear it alone. It doesn't even look like I have lip color on but it gives my lips more depth and just a touch more color. It keeps my glosses and lipsticks from bleeding and is waterproof but fades away when I eat as most liners and lip product do. I think it's a bit pricey for such a small pencil so I removed a star but I do like the quality.This glides on super smooth and doesn't feather. It has a good color payoff and is matte. The only thing I didn't love is the color of Nice Neutral is a little too peachy to match my lips. But if that tone works for you this is a great lip liner.